Why Do We Hate Them, Amma?

Yesterday my dad and RD were watching something on TV and something about Pakistan came up in the news.

R had just come back from playing and she was a mess of dirt and muck and sweat. I was screaming at her to have a bath but she stood still watching the news.

Unlike her usual ‘Amma there is soap in my eyes’ and ‘Amma do fast I am bored of having a bath’ she was pretty silent. Thanking that God who decided to zip her mouth for a while, I quickly gave her a bath. She came quietly, picked up her night clothes and as she was wearing them, she asked me seriously ‘Amma why do we hate them so much?’

I was taken aback for a second. ‘Hate who?’ I asked.

R: The Pakistan people

Me: What? Of course not. Who told you we hate them? Have we ever mentioned about it?

R: Well not you and Appa, but there are people in my school and daycare who say Pakistanis are bad. We should always win our cricket matches against them and that they attack us. Pakistan is not in India na? That is why they hate us? Are they all bad people, Amma?

I must admit this came out of the blue. RD and I have never ever discussed India and Pakistan or mentioned it around her, as far as I remember. I must also confess I am pretty neutral to Pakistan. I have no hatred towards the common folks there and I believe an individual’s behaviour does not reflect a country’s behaviour. 

Me: No R. They are all just people like us. Just like you play with your friends, they play with theirs, just as you bug Amma while combing your hair, they bug theirs and just as you go to school, they go too.

R: So they are like us only?

Me: Yes of course. Some people make some issues in the name of religion and God and cause confusion among everyone. In 1947 when the Britishers decided to leave us, they just divided India into two parts because they felt it would be easier to manage. 

R: But you only say na ‘All Gods are one’. Their Amma didnt teach them this?

Me: Yes. All Gods are one and its just what you believe in at the end of the day. Just because someone says someone is bad, it doesnt make them bad na. Tomorrow if someone says your friend S is bad, will she become bad?

R: No Amma.

She was silent for  a second. 

R: Amma, you know what. I think I have to tell everyone that Pakistanis are just like us, no? 

Me: Yes of course

R: Hmmmm. Ammmaaaa do you think we can go to Pakistan?

Me: Well lets hope we can. Now can we do some English Grammar?

I am wondering what to tell an innocent child who believes inthe  inherent goodness of people, about partition and religion. I think I will just keep it for another day! 


About R's Mom

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Why Do We Hate Them, Amma?

  1. Smita says:

    Kids ask us simplest questions and leave us zapped!!! It is really difficult to answer them some times!!! You handled it quite well.

    And as far as the issue is concerned I am on your side and leaving this aside there are times when I am biased towards things but I ensure that I do not express that bias in front of Arnav coz I want him to take his own decisions.

  2. Deeps says:

    Some things are better left unsaid, RM, if it means keeping our kids’ naivete intact for that extra bit more time. Hugs to R for her pure belief in the goodness of people. You explained it all so well to her.

  3. Aarthi says:

    My child is only 9 months old now but I am already dreading about having to explain all the annoyingly scary things happening in this world to her 😦 I definitely need to improve my communication skills which is ‘nil’ right now. *I wish we lived in fairy land*

  4. Jo says:

    If only people had half the goodness of this innocent child.. Sigh! U r a good mentor RM. U have managed the situation well n has tried thickening the goodness in her.. πŸ™‚

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s